• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Smart Dating Over 60

Mature dating advice to find true love after 60, from both a senior woman's and a senior man's perspective.

  • The Dating Game Plan
  • Women Over 60
  • Men Over 60
  • Start Here . . .
  • First Dates
  • Sex & Romantic Relationships
  • Online Dating
  • Blog
  • About Us
    • About Daisy
    • About Cosmo
  • Shop
    • Mature Dating Game Plan
    • Mature Dating Challenges
    • 10 Disastrous Online Dating Mistakes
    • Mature Singles’ Quick Guide to Smart Dating
    • My account
    • Cart
    • Checkout
  • FREE Dating Tools
    • Newsletter & FREE Ebook
    • Online Dating Profile Writer
    • Dating Calculator – How Long to Date Before Finding “The One”
    • Mature Dating Resources
    • Quiz – Am I Ready for a Relationship?
    • Quiz – Am I in a Healthy Relationship?
    • Share Your Dating Stories
  • Contact Us

April 8, 2024 By Daisy

4 Romantic Notions That Can Keep You From Finding True Love

romantic notions that sabotage love and romance dating over 60

If you’re seriously dating, the last thing you want to do is jeopardize your chances of finding true love.

Over the more than 2 years that I seriously dated in my late 50’s and then again in my early 60’s, a few things happened on first dates, or early on, that led me to believe I had met “the one”.

They were merely coincidences, but with the promise of romance and love in the air, I built them up to be of major importance. Somehow these things convinced me that we were “meant to be”.

Coincidences are an interesting thing. They happen often to all of us. but some of us are not primed to notice them, so we miss them.

And research found that:

“Certain personality traits are linked to experiencing more coincidences—people who describe themselves as religious or spiritual, people who are self-referential (or likely to relate information from the external world back to themselves), and people who are high in meaning-seeking are all coincidence-prone. People are also likely to see coincidences when they are extremely sad, angry, or anxious.”

In my case, I wasted too much time hitching my wagon to men who weren’t capable of having the kind of mature, nurturing relationship I wanted . . . mostly based on coincidental events.

If I had properly assessed these potential relationships from the start, I would have nipped things in the bud, so I’d be open to letting someone in who was right for me.

By the way, the desire to have a special “how we met” story doesn’t plague only women. Plenty of men suffer from it, too.

4 Romantic Notions That May Keep You from Finding True Love

Here are four things from my dating career that I placed too much significance on:

1. My date and I saw a rainbow driving to a restaurant for lunch.

smart dating over 60, finding true love

It was one of those rainbows that seemed to be only a few feet away, over a pond we were driving by. The colors were especially spectacular and distinct from one another, and we could see the entire arching effect.

Even though rainbows ARE pretty special, I read way too much into it.

After seeing the rainbow, we began seeing each other several times a week. The romance lasted for about a month.

But he was all wrong for me. He saw that before I did, and broke things off rather insensitively (by phone). I was devastated for a while, but then realized things weren’t right in the relationship, and I went back at dating seriously again.

I got lucky and met Sam about a month later. If I had stuck with the rainbow guy, I never would have been open to dating Sam.

2. My date and I had the same birthday.

smart dating over 60, romantic notions that don't mean you've found true love

When I look back on the 2 months that I dated this man, I can see so many red flags that I chose to overlook, or just didn’t see, at the time.

This was early in my dating career when I had very little experience dating different kinds of men, so my radar was wobbly, to say the least. I had yet to understand that I was attracted to men who were all wrong for me . . . or for any women (in my opinion).

If I was paying attention, I would have seen right away that he was a manipulative narcissist, just like my ex-husband.

He was incapable of emotional intimacy. And he was a “player” who needed to have dates every weekend night to feel good about himself. So I was just a link in his chain of revolving potential dating prospects.

Also, he was a terrible listener, not much interested in what I had to say. He went radio silent on me several times. He’d often call me for a date last minute. In other words, he was disrespectful in many regards.

The fact that our birthdays were on the same day somehow elevated him in my mind as a potential partner, despite all the red flags.

Clearly, I wasn’t thinking straight. But I can commend myself for figuring it all out fairly quickly. I gave up on him after 2 months, said “No” when he called for a date a few months afterwards, and set my sights on finding someone better suited to me.

3. My date and I shared a love of the same obscure musician.

smart dating over 60, finding true love and romance

Before I met Cosmo in person, we communicated for a week or so by email before moving to phone conversations. From the beginning, we learned that we both had eclectic taste in music. I would email him YouTube videos of people and groups I liked. He did the same with me.

I wanted to assess Cosmo’s musical taste and knowledge, so I sent him a video of Dan Hicks, early in Dan’s career, when he was on the Flip Wilson Show with his band, the Hot Licks.

It struck a chord (pun intended). Turns out, Cosmo was a huge fan as well.

We both came to feel that this shared fandom sealed the deal with our relationship. It seemed to tell us something special about each other.

Of course, that’s pretty much nonsense.

It was a sweet little thing we had in common, but we had so many other good things going for us that made us compatible and soulmates. Surely, our mutual love of Dan Hicks had only a tiny impact on our mutual love.

4. My date and I lived across the street from each other, but only found each other through a dating site.

dating after 60 and finding true love and romance

Well, this was Cosmo again. I’ve mentioned this coincidence several times before on this site, but it really is such a good story, I want to tell it again.

Cosmo had been living on my street for about 7 years before we met. I had been living where we now live together for about 15 years.

Property lots are on the large side here, so neighbors are not located very close together, and are not at all chummy with each other.

I never saw him take out his garbage or walk along the street. Since people here aren’t friends so much, we wouldn’t have met at a neighborhood gathering.

We both know we never would have met, if we hadn’t both been on the same dating site, at the same time.

This is one of the reasons we both recommend online dating to anyone.

A Great “How We Met” Story Isn’t All That Important

Everyone wants a great first date or “how we met” story. This is so important to some people that they invent one.

These things are great, but they don’t indicate that you’ll have a compatible, loving relationship. And they can keep you from finding true love.

Even though two of my romantic notions above resulted in me finding true love with Cosmo, these things in and of themselves did not seal the deal. They’re just endearing little things that happened to us.

Instead of hanging on to some random event as evidence that you’re meant to be, date smart by going into it already knowing who will be right for you.

And, when those magical things happen early in a potential relationship, stop and think.

Are you swooning over that coincidence and having a good story to tell about it, or is this really the right kind of person for you?

The real signs to look for in finding true love are things like these:

  • You feel safe with them.
  • They listen.
  • They acknowledge your differences instead of trying to change you.
  • You can communicate easily.
  • They encourage you to do your own thing.
  • You trust each other.
  • They make an effort.
  • You know you can collaborate or compromise.

Sometimes that good story, like in my case, does go hand-in-hand with having a soulmate relationship. Sometimes it’s just a nice little thing that happened, and no more.

More About Finding True Love and Romance After 60

Senior Dating Tips: How To Calm Your First Date Jitters

Smart Dating Advice for Men Over 60 Looking for True Love

Sex and Dating Over 60: When To Make Love For the First Time

Mature Dating Statistics on Sex and Love

Filed Under: Sex and Romantic Relationships, Single Women Over 60, Who Is My Ideal Partner?

Previous Post: « How to Find Senior Singles Events and Adventures Near You
Next Post: Smart Dating Advice for Men Over 60 Looking for True Love »

Primary Sidebar

Get our free dating over 60 ebook when you subscribe to our popular newsletter

Secret to Dating Success

Free Newsletter & Ebook

* indicates required
Enter your email address

Intuit Mailchimp

Eharmony is our readers’ favorite dating site. Join and find your soulmate, a companion, or just a fun date to hang out with

senior dating

Struggling to write your profile? Try this quick and easy way to write a killer profile that grabs people’s attention

free online dating profile writer

Order your blood tests online and skip the wait for a doctor’s appointment

our dating ebooks

find your soulmate

The Mature Dating Game Plan – The Low-Stress Way to Find Your Soulmate After Divorce or Loss Without Getting Played

mature dating challenges

Mature Dating Challenges – Problems and Road Blocks That Can Keep You From Finding Your Soulmate Later in Life

Are You Making These 10 Disastrous Online Dating Mistakes Are You Making These 10 Disastrous Online Dating Mistakes? Don't sabotage your chances to find love and romance. Our ebook will help you.

Popular Dating Over 60 Articles

Top 10 Best Online Dating Sites for Over 60: How To Choose and Use Them

44 Places Where You Can Meet Singles Over 60

Sex and Mature Dating: When To Make Love For the First Time

How to Use Eharmony for Senior Dating

How To Write a Dazzling Online Dating Profile To Attract Your True Love Faster

Our Best Advice for Better First Dates Over 60

How and Where To Meet Single Men and Women Over 60

Mature Dating and Widowhood: Are You Really Ready for Love Again?

7 Reasons Why Finding True Love Later in Life is Better

How to Attract Your True Love with an Abundance Mentality

Sober Dating When You’re Over 60

Categories

  • First Dates
  • Know Yourself
  • Mature Dating Advice
  • Online Dating
  • Second Dates and Beyond
  • Senior Dating and Families
  • Senior Health and Wellness
  • Sex and Romantic Relationships
  • Single Men Over 60
  • Single Women Over 60
  • Traditional Dating
  • Who Is My Ideal Partner?

Footer

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Mature Dating Resources
  • Share Your Dating Stories

Follow Us Here

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Legal Stuff

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy 

Site Map – Smart Dating Over 60™

Copyright © 2026 · Smart Dating Over 60 LLC · All Rights Reserved

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We\'ll assume you\'re ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Read More

Decline Cookie Settings
Accept

Preferences

Cookies are small text files that can be used by websites to make a user\'s experience more efficient. The law states that we can store cookies on your device if they are strictly necessary for the operation of this site. For all other types of cookies we need your permission. This site uses different types of cookies. Some cookies are placed by third party services that appear on our pages.
  • Necessary
    Always Active
    Necessary cookies help make a website usable by enabling basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website. The website cannot function properly without these cookies.
    Name
    wpl_user_preference
    Domain
    www.smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    WP GDPR Cookie Consent Preferences
    Expiry
    1 year
    Type
    HTTP

  • Marketing
    Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites. The intention is to display ads that are relevant and engaging for the individual user and thereby more valuable for publishers and third party advertisers.

  • Analytics
    Analytics cookies help website owners to understand how visitors interact with websites by collecting and reporting information anonymously.
    Name
    sbjs_migrations
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_current_add
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_first_add
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_current
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_first
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_udata
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Sourcebuster tracking cookie
    Expiry
    54 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    sbjs_session
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    SourceBuster Tracking session
    Expiry
    Session
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    _ga
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Google Universal Analytics long-time unique user tracking identifier.
    Expiry
    2 years
    Type
    HTTP

    Name
    _gid
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    Google Universal Analytics short-time unique user tracking identifier.
    Expiry
    1 days
    Type
    HTTP

  • Preferences
    Preference cookies enable a website to remember information that changes the way the website behaves or looks, like your preferred language or the region that you are in.

  • Unclassified
    Unclassified cookies are cookies that we are in the process of classifying, together with the providers of individual cookies.
    Name
    _ga_ZNXF68N7PZ
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    ---
    Expiry
    2 years
    Type
    ---

    Name
    _gat_gtag_UA_109629167_1
    Domain
    smartdatingover60.com
    Purpose
    ---
    Expiry
    Session
    Type
    ---

    Name
    _mcid
    Domain
    mc.us17.list-manage.com
    Purpose
    ---
    Expiry
    1 year
    Type
    ---

    Name
    _abck
    Domain
    list-manage.com
    Purpose
    ---
    Expiry
    1 year
    Type
    ---

    Name
    bm_sz
    Domain
    list-manage.com
    Purpose
    ---
    Expiry
    Session
    Type
    ---

Cookie Settings